Trading video games online is one of the most popular ways to expand your gaming library without breaking the bank. Whether you're clearing out old titles or hunting for classics, this guide will help you trade video games safely and successfully.
Why Trade Video Games?
Video games lose value quickly after release, making them perfect for bartering. Instead of letting old games collect dust, you can trade them for new experiences. Plus, trading helps:
- Save money – Get new games without spending cash
- Build community – Connect with fellow gamers
- Reduce waste – Keep games in circulation instead of landfills
- Try new titles – Experiment with games you might not buy
Step 1: Assess Your Game's Value
Before listing your game for trade, understand its market value. Check these factors:
- Platform – PS5, Xbox Series X, Nintendo Switch, and PC games hold value differently
- Release date – Newer games (under 6 months) are worth more
- Condition – Complete with case, manual, and working disc/cartridge
- Popularity – AAA titles and exclusives trade better than budget games
- Rarity – Limited editions and out-of-print games can be valuable
Use sites like PriceCharting.com or check recent 37th Place trades to gauge fair market value.
Step 2: Create a Compelling Listing
Your listing is your sales pitch. Include these key elements:
Essential Information
- Full game title and platform (e.g., "The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom - Nintendo Switch")
- Condition rating – Be honest! (Like New, Good, Acceptable)
- What's included – Original case, manual, DLC codes, special edition items
- Clear photos – Show front, back, disc/cartridge, and any damage
Pro Tips for Better Listings
- Mention if it's a physical or digital code (digital codes can be emailed instantly!)
- List what games you're seeking in return
- Be specific about your preferred platform
- Note your location for local pickup options
Step 3: Evaluate Trade Offers
When offers come in, consider these factors:
- Value match – Is the trade roughly equal in market value?
- Your interest – Would you actually play what you're getting?
- Trader reputation – Check their reviews and trade history
- Shipping costs – Factor in who pays for shipping
"I traded three old PS4 games I'd finished for one new PS5 game I really wanted. The other trader was happy to bundle, and I got an amazing deal!" - Mike, 37th Place user
Step 4: Negotiate Fairly
Not every offer will be perfect. Here's how to negotiate:
- Counter with specifics – "Could you add [game title] to make it even?"
- Suggest cash + game – Sometimes a small cash add makes everyone happy
- Bundle deals – Trade multiple games to get a higher-value item
- Be respectful – Polite traders get better deals and repeat partners
Step 5: Ship Safely
Once you agree on a trade, protect your game during shipping:
Packing Your Game
- Use a bubble mailer or small box with padding
- Wrap the game case in bubble wrap
- Seal securely with packing tape
- Include a friendly note and your 37th Place username
Shipping Smart
- Get tracking – Always use tracked shipping (USPS First Class is affordable)
- Ship simultaneously – Send your game the same day as your trade partner
- Communicate – Share tracking numbers immediately
- Confirm receipt – Message when you receive their game
Red Flags to Watch For
Protect yourself by avoiding these warning signs:
- ❌ User has no trade history or reviews
- ❌ They want you to ship first without verification
- ❌ Blurry photos or no photos at all
- ❌ Vague condition descriptions
- ❌ Pressure to trade quickly without discussion
- ❌ They won't provide tracking information
If something feels off, trust your gut and decline the trade. There are always more opportunities!
Special Tips for Different Platforms
Nintendo Switch
Nintendo games hold value better than most. First-party titles (Mario, Zelda, Pokémon) rarely drop below $40 even years after release. Physical Switch games are perfect for trading because there's no account linking.
PlayStation 5 & Xbox Series X
Current-gen console games are in high demand. If you have launch titles or exclusives, you're in a great position. Remember: PS5 disc games won't work on Digital Edition consoles, so specify clearly.
PC Games (Physical/Digital Codes)
Digital PC codes are instant trades! If you have unused game keys from Humble Bundle or other sources, they're perfect for quick swaps. Always clarify which platform (Steam, Epic, GOG) and region.
Retro Games
Classic games for NES, SNES, Genesis, PS1, and other retro systems can be very valuable. Research before trading – you might have a hidden gem!
Maximize Your Trading Success
- Build a reputation – Complete trades promptly and leave reviews
- Be responsive – Reply to messages within 24 hours
- Take great photos – Good lighting makes your games look better
- Update listings – Mark items as traded so you don't get duplicate offers
- Join the community – Participate in forums and discussions
Final Thoughts
Trading video games online is fun, economical, and sustainable. With these tips, you'll build a great gaming collection while connecting with fellow gamers. Start with smaller trades to build confidence, communicate clearly, and always prioritize safety.
Ready to start trading? Head over to 37th Place and list your first game today!